The girl had a lot to explain, about mysteriously appearing from a portal, then calling you "dad".
"Okay... this is weird, my name is, uh, Abigail, after my mom, and, well, I'm... from the future." You thought about that for a moment, maybe this was part of your wish... "And see... I'm kinda..."
"My daughter, right? In the future..." you interrupted.
"Well, yeah. This'll sound crazy, but I found this!" She said, pulling a golden lamp out of her pocket, the very same one on your coffee table right now.
"I believe you." You said, grabbing your lamp and showing it to her. "The genie... it brought you here..."
"Yeah... It did. I wanted to know more about the past, you and mom never told me anything about how you guys met and, well, when I found it in a drawer, the genie came out and told me he could grant me my wish, and brought me back to around the time you guys met."
The two of you had a lot to talk about...